Skip to content

Family Lawyer Services in Naperville IL

Family Law – Divorce and Child Custody Dispute in Naperville, IL

A Case Study in Dissolution of Marriage disputes


To understand the steps involved in a successful divorce and child custody issues in Naperville courts, we have assembled the following hypothetical so you can understand the complexities of family law resolution.

John and Jane Doe, a married couple residing in Naperville, IL, decided to divorce after 10 years of marriage. They have two children, Emily (8 years old) and Jack (5 years old). Both John and Jane work full-time, and they disagree on who should have primary custody of the children.


  1. Child Custody and Visitation: Both parents want primary custody of the children.
  2. Child Support: Determining the appropriate amount of child support.
  3. Parental Rights: Ensuring both parents maintain a meaningful relationship with the children.
  4. Best Interests of the Children: Ensuring decisions are made in the best interests of Emily and Jack.

Legal Process

Step 1: Filing for Divorce

Jane filed for divorce citing irreconcilable differences in Will County court that covers the Naperville area. Along with the divorce petition, she requested primary custody of the children.

Step 2: Temporary Orders

During the initial hearing, the court issued temporary orders to establish a temporary custody and visitation schedule, and temporary child support payments. John was granted visitation rights on weekends.

Step 3: Mediation

The Will County court mandated mediation to help John and Jane reach a mutually agreeable custody arrangement. In mediation, both parents expressed their concerns and preferences:

  • Jane preferred primary custody due to her flexible work schedule.
  • John wanted joint custody, emphasizing his active involvement in the children’s lives.
Step 4: Custody Evaluation

Since mediation did not result in an agreement, the court ordered a custody evaluation by a licensed evaluator. The evaluator assessed both parents’ living situations, interviewed the children, and observed interactions between the parents and children.

Step 5: Court Hearing

Based on the evaluation and recommendations, a court hearing was scheduled. The evaluator recommended joint custody with a structured visitation schedule:

  • Emily and Jack would live primarily with Jane during the school week.
  • John would have the children every other weekend and two evenings per week.
  • Holidays and summer vacations would be shared equally.
Step 6: Final Custody and Support Order

The judge reviewed the evaluator’s report, listened to both parents’ arguments, and considered the best interests of the children. The final custody order was as follows:

  • Joint Legal Custody: Both parents have the right to make important decisions regarding the children’s education, health, and welfare.
  • Physical Custody: Jane was granted primary physical custody.
  • Visitation Schedule: John was granted visitation every other weekend, two weekday evenings, and half of the holidays and summer vacation.
  • Child Support: John was ordered to pay child support based on Illinois Child Support Guidelines, considering both parents’ incomes and the time spent with each parent.


The structured visitation schedule ensured that both parents maintained significant involvement in their children’s lives. The court’s decision focused on the best interests of Emily and Jack, providing stability while allowing them to have meaningful relationships with both parents.

Lessons Learned

  1. Best Interests of the Child: The court prioritizes the children’s well-being over the parents’ preferences.
  2. Mediation and Evaluation: Mediation and professional evaluations play crucial roles in resolving custody disputes.
  3. Structured Visitation: Clear and structured visitation schedules help minimize conflicts and provide stability for children.
  4. Parental Cooperation: Effective co-parenting and communication are essential for the children’s emotional and psychological well-being.

This case study illustrates the complexities and legal processes involved in family law disputes, emphasizing the importance of focusing on the best interests of the children while navigating custody and support issues.